It's been a week. A week of learning. A week of terror. A week of struggle. Frankly it doesn't make it any different from any other week.
Except. I decided to write about it. Which in and of itself is part of the problem.
I have no idea where it came from. I don't know the idea from whence it was born. It wasn't given to me explicitly by my parents or upbringing. It wasn't an expressed command from a higher power. It wasn't rules or laws magically burned into stone. It was just me. Growing up. In the era and time that I did.
I honestly think I'm Batman.
And if not him, then I am meant to be a hero. To save others. To protect.
What I ever really understood is that no one needs my protection. No one expects me to be a hero. There is no one to save.
Except me.
Yeah. Yeah. Hero save thyself. How trite. How quaint.
I wrote the above several years ago and never posted it. I felt it was whiny. It was not that introspective or original. But recently I have been thinking about Batman again. Zack Snyder, the once herald of DC Comic movies and their tone said that "Batman kills, Superman kills, Get over it" I was interested in Snyder's vision for DC's universe at first. But this just once again shows that he wasn't the right man for the job. He wanted to tear down the ideals of Batman and Superman, make them "modern". And while that might work for 300 or even some elements of Marvel or The Umbrella Academy, Runaways and other fringe comic related properties, it doesn't work for icons. Snyder wanted to watch the comic world burn and missed the point that his audience didn't.
His tone and cinematic style are enjoyable to watch. He would have been the perfect director for a Moon Night or Lobo movie. Play fast and lose with the rules, break walls, break convention. But he took that tactic to the wrong properties. Batman turned 80 today. You can't fight that much history. It's like remaking the Babe and having George Human Ruth be a vegan who is into Crossfit. You simply took it a bridge or continent too far.
I feel that Snyder is an amazing director. But DC was so desperate to separate themselves from Marvel, they lost the plot. The pendulum swung so far that they couldn't hold it from swinging out of control. It happens in sports and business all the time. We fired this leader so we need to find someone the polar opposite. They go too far and then they find another opposite for the next job. Look at what happened when they replaced Snyder. They went to JJ Abrams, proven hit maker and subtle boat rocker.
Today is Batman's 80th birthday. In a sense. More often than not over the past 80 years the one thing that seperated batman from his villians was murder. He broke the law over and over again. Breaking and entering. Stealing evidence. Assault on a daily basis. Not to mention how he could use his wealth and prividlege to consistently evade consequences. From assault charges, to speeding, to using drones without proper FAA clearance.
He broke a lot of rules. But one of the things that made him different from his foes was murder. Yeah he would beat you up and then tie you up but it was never with a limb or a lung missing. When Zach Snyder casually says Batman kills people. He proves that his Batman was never based on the history.
Snyder wrote an Elseworlds story. A What if? He was brought in to do that very thing, challenge the status quo. And DC is in a bad place overall because of it. They have taken their two most marketable icons, Batman and Superman and have tarnished them. Meanwhile, Aquaman and Wonder Woman have thrived. Flash on TV is good and Flash in the movie is a blatant rip off of the Spiderman/Iran Man Marvel dynamic.
But here is were DC's troubled comic history can actually make all this work. Admit your TV heroes are more loved than your movie heroes. And then drop the ultimate reset that is already cannon.
Crisis on Infinity Earths.
Bring it all together. The CW version of Arrow, Supergirl, Flash and others. But keep your broken movie versions as well. Epic battle after battle. Let Ezra Miller's Flash try to bet the TV version. Let both versions of the Suicide Squad face off. Make Supergirl from TV shame the movie version of her cousin for being a 90s emo kid.
The possibilities are endless. In the comics when DC realized it had gone way too far and needed a purge, the crisis was the answer.
DC remember your history, take all of these disparete parts and reset. Don't reboot and pretend this time you have it figured out, own your mess cinematic and TV recent history or hell even bring back past versions of all. Do you really think Michelle Pffiefer as Catwoman vs Halle Berry vs the young Selina from Gotham wouldn't be worth the price of admission? Or a Luthor face off of Hackman, Jesse Eisenbern and Michael Rosenbaum wouldn't be interesting?
DC you have massively failed this version. But look to your history and bring all of the infinite versions together. Make it epic and take back the icons.
Snyder wanted to let them all kill and die. Your true power and your most unique story can be your inspiration, let all the versions live, at once and then sort them out.
Just don't bring back Jason Todd and let us vote...